
by Frank Andorka, Managing Editor
Pretexting, cemented in the popular imagination by TV shows like “The Rockford Files” and “Magnum, P.I.,” has long been considered a central piece of a private investigator’s tradecraft.
Today, the legality and permissibility of it is more nuanced. With the exception of a couple of specific federal carve-outs for medical, phone or bank records, states are left on their own to decide what is allowable. About 15 states, including Ohio, California and Connecticut, explicitly ban “pretext interviews” by statute, but only for insurance claims. In the rest, there’s no law specifically against it.
Even in the federal courts, there’s no bright line: Sometimes pretexting is allowed, and sometimes it’s not, depending on the circumstances. The result is that the issue continues to be litigated extensively. Impossible Foods v. Motif FoodWorks is one such case where private investigators deployed an elaborate web of pretexts, all to get a plant-based burger — really — from their competitor.
The case had everything: three private investigation firms, an elaborate pretext that lasted 16 months and targeted trade shows across the country, and a blown cover because a private investigator forgot to change her name to her “alias” before hopping on a Zoom call with the target.
The details are as juicy as a real hamburger. Let’s get into it.
Background
It all started with plant-based burgers. Impossible Foods (Impossible) believed Motif FoodWorks (Motif) had stolen their patented idea to use heme proteins to simulate beef taste and texture, so they sued them in 2022. The problem was they couldn’t be absolutely sure of the theft without a sample of Motif’s burger. As they prepared to sue Motif, Impossible simultaneously hired private investigators starting in December 2021 to catch Motif red-handed and get actual samples.
Unlike Impossible burgers, which anyone can get at Kroger or Walmart, Motif only sold its products to commercial clients. Over the next 16 months, three private investigative firms dogged Motif at trade shows across the United States.
Impossible’s law firm, Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati PC (WSGR), started by hiring T&M USA, a New York-based investigation company, to help by sending an investigator to Plant Based World Expo to get a sample. The first deception occurred there: Bill Weller, a T&M employee, represented himself as affiliated with the Centerport Yacht Club and later emailed Motif that a friend of his represented a Manhattan restaurant group that was interested in its product. Motif told him its patties wouldn’t be in production until October 2022. He did not get the sample Impossible wanted.
Three months later, in March 2022, Impossible tried again. An employee from Paramount Investigative Services in Los Angeles visited Motif’s booth at Future Food-Tech in San Francisco. This time the investigator succeeded where the previous one had failed.
Impossible sued Motif that same month.
Enter Food4Thought
Not satisfied with the samples Paramount obtained in March, T&M doubled down on pretexting Motif. T&M went on to create an entirely fictitious meal kit company called Food4Thought so they could engage with Motif as a potential commercial customer. As part of those efforts, T&M hired a subcontracting firm called Integrity One Solutions, another investigative firm out of New York, to supply investigators to attend two more trade shows. At the second show, investigators approached the Motif booth, where both cooked and raw samples of Motif’s burgers were available.
They identified themselves as “Ed Barry” and “Sarah Jamil” of Food4Thought, and asked for samples. Barry and Jamil represented to the Motif booth managers that they were considering a partnership with the company. The Motif employees passed the lead to their director of business development, who set up a Zoom call with the fake company to discuss the plan. The pretexting investigators joined the Zoom audio-only, just names, no faces.
Here’s where a simple mistake blew the entire investigation. “Sarah Jamil” forgot to change her Zoom identifier from her real name, Sarah Nasir, to “Sarah Jamil.” During the call, Nasir realized her error and changed the screen name to her alias, but the sharp-eyed Motif director noticed the change and wondered what the heck was going on. Further investigation revealed Food4Thought’s website was, in the court’s words, “very rudimentary.” There was also no mention of Weller or Nasir on it (oops). Based on getting that small but crucial detail wrong, Motif traced Sarah Nasir back to Integrity One Solutions. The covers were blown.
Even so, Nasir and Weller kept after the case. They emailed the director multiple times trying to get samples under a new “direct-to-consumer sampling program.”
Motif was angry. Already in litigation with Impossible, they cried foul and sent a “cease and desist” letter to Impossible, demanding the company stop its investigation. Impossible’s stance was that it had concluded its investigation, but Motif wasn’t satisfied. They complained to the court that Impossible must pay a higher price.
Motif then sought a protective order to bar Impossible from further pre-texted investigations. It also demanded sanctions against Impossible and its law firm, WSGR, for running the sting operation in the first place.
(story continues below)

(story continues)
The Judge’s Decision
Motif argued that WSGR violated four American Bar Association (ABA) rules through its use of private investigators to deceive employees of a party known to be represented by counsel in pending litigation (the patent case that started all of this): Rule 4.1, Rule 4.2, Rule 5.3 and Rule 8.4.
ABA Rule 4.1 requires attorneys to not knowingly make false statements to others, and ABA Rule 4.2 is the “no contact” rule and is one of the most basic rules in litigation: once a party has a lawyer, the attorney on the other side has to go through that lawyer.
While these are rules that attorneys are held to, private investigators working for attorneys are seen as their “agents,” and the attorneys often must answer for the behavior of the investigators they hire.
So as a general matter, if you’re working for the law firm on one side of an active lawsuit and you’re contacting people at the company on the other side about the dispute, you’re doing exactly what the attorney who retained you is barred from doing. That’s what made Motif’s argument look strong on paper.
In response to Motif’s arguments, United States Circuit Judge William C. Bryson, a judge on the Federal Circuit (the specialized appeals court for patent cases), considered both sides of the argument and delivered his decision on May 31, 2023.
In his decision, Bryson acknowledged the lack of precedent in pretexting involving “employees” of represented organizations, drawing a distinction between “represented individuals” and organizations. Bryson went on to explain that federal court position on pretexting varies widely, is “heavily fact-dependent” and that “courts have not set forth a bright-line rule indicating precisely when such pretextual investigations are permissible and when they are not.”
In other words, there is no clear federal standard.
After reviewing the facts of this case, Bryson found Impossible and its lawyers had not violated any governing ethical rules because they had not tricked or coerced any Motif employees to talk to them, and the samples were available to all trade show attendees. He gave three reasons this case was different from the ones where investigators got sanctioned: the investigators dealt with booth staff, not executives; they were after samples, not admissions; and nobody recorded anything. From a practical perspective, Motif didn’t treat its products as proprietary (and those they did, the ingredient list and preparation methods, were rightly denied by Motif at the booths). As a result, he found no harm had been done by the pretexting the investigators used. He found Motif had neither proved harm enough to warrant a protective order, nor did it prove WSGR had violated the ABA’s ethical standards.
The Industry Reacts
The question of pretexting continues to be a sensitive topic in the profession. Of course, when and if to use it as a tool in your investigative toolbox can vary depending on what state you live in as well as the details of the case you’re working on.
Mike Thompson, a Texas Board Certified Investigator (TBCI), owner of Dallas-based firm Ideal Intel and president of the Texas Association of Licensed Investigators (TALI), says pretexting, despite what many investigators think, isn’t always the best way to elicit critical information in a case.
“When you’re deciding to pretext, you need to ask yourself whether it’s worth it,” Thompson says. “You can often get the same information by being straightforward because people just like to talk.”
John Morris, owner and chief investigator at EVCO Investigations in Greeley, Colorado, who reviewed the Impossible Foods case at the request of Working PI, says the first thing a private investigator needs to examine is the laws in the state in which they’re working. Specifically, they should determine whether any laws in the state prevent pretexting. Secondly, they should consult with their licensing board and see if using a pretext violates any ethical obligations they have under their licensure.
“In both cases, the regulations and laws may not use the word pretext itself,” Morris says. “Private investigators should look at language about giving false information to gather evidence.”
Additionally, Morris says private investigators must do an internal gut check to make sure what they’re being asked to do comports with their own internal ethical standards. “One of the biggest considerations for private investigators really needs to be what they think they can stomach,” Morris says. “How much risk are they willing to take when it comes to gathering information through pretext or any form of deceit?”
Morris says he has used and will continue to use pretexting on certain cases but not if he’s working directly for a lawyer for a company. “I would err on the side of caution and never do a pretext [under those circumstances],” he adds.
Practically speaking, Morris says he does not believe the findings in this case make it any clearer whether pretexting as a private investigator is ethical or legal.
“If you talk to 100 private investigators, you would probably get 100 different opinions regarding the topic,” Morris says. “It’s definitely a controversial topic and one that doesn’t seem as if it will be resolved anytime soon.”
(story continues below)

(story continues)
Pretexting Guidelines
Bryson’s decision in this case is useful: It states that investigators, and their counsel, were not sanctioned for engaging with represented persons within the limited confines of the case details, i.e., collecting samples that were also offered to the public and other businesses.
Additionally, there are some other general pretexting guidelines:
1. Varies by State: Investigators would be wise to start with their own state’s rules and legal precedents. If you’re in a licensing state, it’s likely that the licensing board has power to discipline you for “dishonesty or fraud” or “fraud or deceit” in the practice of your business. California’s courts have applied that language to investigators twice. In Taylor (1954), an investigator working for a plaintiff’s lawyer told the defendant he represented the defendant’s insurance company; in Wayne (1962), an investigator working for plaintiffs’ lawyers let the people his clients were suing believe he was from their own insurer, without ever saying so outright. Both lost their licenses for a stretch. About 15 states, California included, prohibit pretext interviews on insurance matters unless there’s a reasonable basis to suspect fraud.
2. Often Litigated: Pretexting and undercover work are almost always challenged in court. The opposing party, when caught red-handed and facing evidence that is damaging to their case, will object to the evidence and ask the judge to throw it out. This means, as a private investigator, if you’re considering pretexting as an investigative strategy, you need to do it with the full blessing of your client and plan, document, and strategize it carefully so the evidence gathered will hold up in court.
What helped Impossible’s investigators was that they recorded nothing, took nothing confidential and that the investigation was already over before Motif complained.
3. Pretexting Has Clear No-Nos: Pretending to be a cop or a government employee is a crime everywhere, as is using a pretext to get someone’s phone, bank or medical records.
4. Has Some Federal Guidance: Bryson was right that there’s no bright line, but the cases sort into a few buckets.
A. Posing as a member of the public is generally OK. In Gidatex v. Campaniello Imports (2000), a furniture maker hired two investigators to pose as interior designers. One visited the defendant’s showroom three times, recorded her conversations with the sales clerks and asked about pieces sold under the plaintiff’s trademark. The court found no violation, because the investigators did nothing but observe and record how the clerks conducted routine business and never tricked them into saying anything they wouldn’t have said to a real designer. Hill v. Shell Oil (2002) put the rule in one sentence: Investigators can’t trick protected employees into doing or saying things they otherwise wouldn’t, but they can play customers seeking service on the same basis as the general public. Bryson extended that to a fake company, since Motif only sold business-to-business.
B. Catching ongoing illegal conduct. Courts are most forgiving when a pretext is the practical way to catch someone breaking the law or a court order. In Chloé v. DesignersImports.com (2009), the French fashion house went after an online seller of counterfeit Chloé handbags, and its investigator posed as a customer to document the sales. When the seller complained about the deception, the judge wrote that it is difficult to imagine any trademark investigator announcing her true identity and purpose to a suspected seller of counterfeit goods. A 2005 Cartier trademark case stated the principle the way most courts now do: A lawyer’s use of an undercover investigator to detect ongoing violations of the law is not ethically prohibited, “especially when it would be difficult to discover the violations by other means.” Impossible fit the pattern because the suspected violation was patent infringement. Bryson did note that if the evidence is available in discovery, that cuts against the pretext.
C. Digging into an adversary’s personal life is where courts draw a hard line. In Meyer v. Kalanick (2016), the antitrust suit against Uber’s then-CEO, the defense hired an investigator who contacted 28 friends and professional colleagues of the plaintiff and his lawyer, giving each a false reason for the call. The court found a violation, saying the investigator had undermined the truth-seeking function of litigation by using fraud to dig into adversaries through their personal and business acquaintances. Bryson’s distinction was simple: Impossible’s investigators were after evidence of the conduct alleged in the complaint, not dirt on the people on the other side.
D. Contacting represented parties is not clear-cut. It comes down to who you talk to and what you’re after. In Site 2020 v. Superior Traffic Services (2023), a patent case, the plaintiff’s employee used a fake name, posed as an employee of a company the plaintiff had quietly acquired and sat through a recorded product demonstration of more than an hour with the defendant’s CEO. In the Q&A afterward, the CEO gave detailed answers on topics that went to the heart of the patent claims and then walked the plaintiff’s employee through marketing and regulatory strategy in a conference room. The court called it what it was: an undisclosed, recorded, ex parte interview of the opposing party’s president on the merits. Midwest Motor Sports v. Arctic Cat (2003) went the same way when an investigator posing as a customer recorded a dealership salesman to collect admissions for trial and then questioned the owner. Impossible’s investigators talked to booth staff and a sales contact, got nothing that could be pinned on Motif and recorded nothing. Nothing in these cases blesses pretexting a represented individual about his own case. Assume that one is off limits.
The Last Word
The burger war itself ended the way most of these things end, quietly and in a filing. In September 2024, two and a half years after Impossible sued, the companies settled. Judge Bryson signed the dismissal order. Impossible took over Motif’s heme business, each side paid its own lawyers, and a few days later Motif told its employees it was closing. The ingredient at the heart of the burger Impossible’s investigators spent 16 months chasing now belongs to Impossible.
So what did we learn? First, a pretext can survive a sanctions fight in federal court when the investigators act like customers and nothing more, and a judge was willing to extend that to a fake company because Motif only sold to businesses.
Second, as the judge explained, these cases turn on their facts and are almost always litigated heavily. But a few patterns hold up across the cases. Showing up as a customer and taking what’s offered to anyone has mostly been tolerated. Showing up as the investigator from the other side’s own insurance company, and using that to get something they would never hand you knowingly, has not.
A California court put it about as well as anyone has, back in 1954, when an investigator who had his license suspended for 60 days argued on appeal that his trade runs on tricks and ruses and gets nowhere by the direct approach. The judges didn’t disagree. Sherlock Holmes’ false whiskers, they said, are one thing. Telling the man across the table that you work for his insurance company is another. Seventy years and one plant-based burger later, that’s still about where the line is.
About the Author
Frank Andorka is the Managing Editor of Working PI magazine, published by OREP Insurance, a leading provider of E&O insurance for private investigators nationwide. Andorka has more than two decades of award-winning experience as a writer and editor and is based out of Cleveland, Ohio. He earned a BA in History from The College of Wooster in Wooster, Ohio, and a MA in Modern German History from Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana.
We’re always listening. Send your story submission/idea to the Editor: kendra@orep.org.
